Friday, February 1, 2008

The Winograd Report : You should respect this people

You should respect the Israelis for their democracy and how they care that much for their country and how they try to learn from their mistakes so they won't repeat it for the sake of their people and their country and for the sake of what they believe in. They do not favour this or that because of his or her position or his or her family or what he or she had done in their past from glorious services marked in the Nation's book.

Today the final Winograd Report was published in Israel today and with it the future of Ehud Olmert is being determined whether to stay or to leave , the right wing does not want him anymore but the left wing wants him.

First what is the Wingordad Report ??

It is a report that is representing the findings of the governmental commission led by Eliyahu Wingordad to investigate the results of the Second Lebanon War 2006 , to know why Israel did not achieve any of its goals .

This is the final report.

Here is the main findings in English from Ha'atrz newspaper. Also there is interesting report in the same newspaper regarding the report you should read too.

Wingordad's report in my point of view proves that Hezbollah won the war . Look to what Wingordad said in today Press Conference :

"Israel embarked on a prolonged war that it initiated, which ended without a clear Israeli victory from a military standpoint .A paramilitary organization withstood the strongest army in the Middle East for weeks.Hezbollah rocket fire on the Israeli home front continued throughout the war, and the IDF failed to provide an effective response "

Yes Lebanon Paid a heavy price too but if you look in the past wars with Israel , we always pay heavier price than the Israelis , not to mention that Lebanon not the South of Lebanon was alone in the world , blockaded , with no air shield except very week air defense "compared to the Israelis'" . On the other hand Israel has the state of Art army and defense in the world and could not through out 60 days to even stop rockets from raining over its cities.

From Wingordad report's the deadly mistake was in the ground operation:

The manner in which the ground operation was conducted raises the most difficult of questions

This report is blaming the leadership for the losses by finding "grave faults and failings in the decision-making process and the preparatory work both in the political and military levels and the interaction between them "

The decision making in the political level is  under huge attacks , Winograd reached that the IDF entered the war especially the ground operation without clear.

Believe me the IDF and the Israelis will take this report and fix all their mistakes in order to win a second round , the Israelis always learn and plan based on their past wars and its mistakes.

Olmert refuses to resign as he depends on the Left wing support represented in Barack and his party , the card he is playing with is the Negotiations with the Palestinians "as if it were negotiations with any useful results ??!!"

Days will tell if Olmert will stay in his office or not ,already I do not think that he will stay too long .

After 1967 six days war , an Egyptian official committee was formed to investigate the reasons of the defeat , till this day after 30 years , we do not know yet the findings of the committee , in fact till now we do not know yet how many Egyptians whether from the civilians or from the military were killed in that war !!???

3 comments:

  1. Appauling... Good thing I am not an Arab or a Muslim..

    Do you really believe the 1967 war was a defeat? What is your definition of defeat? The western definition? Oh pleeeease, spare me..

    The reason why Egypt could not form a proper comitee to investigate why the war ended in a temporary loss of territory, was because they already knew the answers. Egypt had the man power to involve itself in a perpetual war. Many Arab nations would have continiously aided them in finance at the very least.

    The reason why Egypt was 'so calleded defeated' was because Egypt cared enough about its entire population not to put them into that kind of turmoil. Look at Egypt's losses... That is not consistent with a war. If Egypt had really fought Israel there would have been enormous losses on both sides. Look at the Iran Iraq war. That is a proper war. This was a limited war, and they settled it earlier. Egypt has become more prosperous because it did not engage in a perpetual war. Sympathies were still high for the Israelis.

    reply back if you wish w0rldl3ad3r@hotmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  2. @teddybear, yes we did not fight back in 1967 , in fact if we fought may be the Israelis did not win the war like , it is true we did not fight and it was not because the Israeli great army it was because of the commandership of the army and the country then because look what happened in
    the 1973 war , do not you consider this war , why Israel was defeated in it ??
    we were engaged back in war in 1973 please check back history
    why do you think the Marcava tank was made by the IDF ???
    By the way just for your information an investigation committee was formed in 1967 but its results were never announced publicly

    ReplyDelete
  3. @Teddybear
    Why are you giving out your email address. Can't we reply back here? You sure have bad spelling for a person who writes English and you seem to know a lot about this topic for a non Arab and a non muslim. Must be a hobby of yours. You seem very pro-Egyptian for a non-Egyptian. Also interesting.

    Zeinobia. Mish 3arfa oulik eh? Dah mish ra7h yi sibik khaliss. Rabbina yi kun fi 3ounik.

    ReplyDelete

Thank You for your comment
Please keep it civilized here, racist and hateful comments are not accepted
The Comments in this blog with exclusion of the blog's owner does not represent the views of the blog's owner.